Casting | Rôle |
|---|
| Joshua Zeman | Himself |
| Barbara Brancaccio | Herself |
| Bill Ellis | Himself - Professor of Folklore, Penn State |
| Dorothy D'Eletto | Herself - Archivist & Researcher |
| Geraldo Rivera | Himself - Reporter (archive footage) |
| Karen Schweiger | Herself - Jennifer Schweiger's Mother |
| David Navarro | Himself - Former Newscaster |
| Donna Cutugno | Herself - Founder, Friends of Jennifer |
| Ralph Aquino | Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD |
| Bobby Jensen | Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD |
| Ernie Anastos | Himself - Reporter (archive footage) |
| Andre Rand | Himself - Suspect |
| Jim Callaghan | Himself - Former Editor, Staten Island Eagle |
| Jim Dolan | Himself - Reporter (archive footage) |
| Theresa Doyle | Herself - Searcher for Jennifer |
| Ed Armstrong | Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother |
| Sean Hughes | Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Brother (archive footage) |
| Peter Hughes | Himself - Holly Ann Hughes's Father |
| Holly Cederholm | Herself - Holly Ann Hughes's Mother |
| Ken Schweiger | Himself - Jennifer Schweiger's Father |
| John O'Brien | Himself - Reporter, Staten Island Advance |
| Duane Felton | Himself - Defense Attorney for Andre Rand |
| Larry Simon | Himself - Defense Attorney for Andre Rand |
| William L. Murphy | Himself - Staten Island District Attorney |
| Trina Cutugno | Herself - Donna's Daughter |
| Devin Cutugno | Himself - Donna's Son |
| Jimmy Rassias | Himself - Former Clerk, Port Richmond Deli |
| Kristine Gosling | Herself - Det. Sgt. Missing Persons Squad, Long Term Cases, NYPD |
| Luis Rivera | Himself - Retired Canine Officer, NYPD |
| Frank Saez | Himself - Ret. Det. Missing Persons Squad, Long Term Cases, NYPD |
| Jack Whitford | Himself - Stapleton Civilian Observation Patrol |
| Thomas Jenkins | Himself - Staten Island Resident |
| Bob Graham | Himself - Acquaintance of Rand |
| Frances Auriti | Herself - Searcher, Friend of Jennifer |
| Tracy Begley | Herself - Searcher, Friend of Jennifer |
| Glenn Chapman | Himself - Former Reporter, Staten Island Advance |
| Leonard D'Alessandro | Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD |
| Martha Hinton | Herself - Witness |
| Frank Marchionne | Himself - Retired Detective, NYPD |
| Tanya Goodson | Herself - Witness |
| Rita Dimartino | Herself - Aunt of Alice Pereira |
| Charles G. Muskett Sr. | Himself - Former Minister |
| Steve Bogen | Himself |
| Patricia Caridad | Herself |
| Robert Caruso | Himself |
| Greg Cusick | Himself |
| Charlie Cutugno | Himself |
| Daniel M. Donovan Jr. | Himself - District Attorney for Richmond County |
| Marla Dziergowski | Herself |
| Robert Foster | Himself |
| Melissa Grace | Herself |
| Judah Lazarus | Himself |
| Bruce Meyersen | Himself |
| Thomas Micol | Himself - Staten Island Resident |
| Carolyn Muskett | Herself |
| Marie Piazza | Herself |
| Lorraine Shanley | Herself |
| Brett Straniere | Himself |
