Casting | Rôle |
|---|
| Noelle Parker | Amy Fisher (archive footage from "Amy Fisher: My Story") |
| Drew Barrymore | Amy Fisher (archive footage from "The Amy Fisher Story") |
| Alyssa Milano | Amy Fisher (archive footage from "Casualties of Love") |
| Ed Marinaro | Joey Buttafuoco (archive footage from "Amy Fisher: My Story") |
| Tony Denison | Joey Buttafuoco (archive footage from "The Amy Fisher Story") |
| Jack Scalia | Joey Buttafuoco (archive footage from "Casualties of Love") |
| Kathleen Laskey | Mary Jo Buttafuoco (archive footage from "Amy Fisher: My Story") |
| Laurie Paton | Mary Jo Buttafuoco (archive footage from "The Amy Fisher Story") |
| Phyllis Lyons | Mary Jo Buttafuoco (archive footage from "Casualties of Love") |
| Boyd Kestner | Paul Makely (archive footage from "Amy Fisher: My Story") |
| Philip Maurice Hayes | Paul Makely (archive footage from "The Amy Fisher Story") |
| Michael Bowen | Paul Makely (archive footage from "Casualties of Love") |
